Mr. Book just finished Promise Me, America, by Joe Biden.
Mr. Book approached Promise Me, America with relatively low expectations. His opinions about Joe Biden are complicated, and a full discussion of those opinions would go well beyond the scope of a book review. Suffice it to say that Mr. Book was not expecting to be particularly impressed by Biden’s account of his presidency.
He was pleasantly surprised.
Biden presents a compelling defense of his administration’s accomplishments while offering a sharply critical assessment of his predecessor and successor, Donald Trump. He makes a strong case for the significance of his legislative achievements, his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, his efforts to restore America’s international standing, and his administration’s response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Among the accomplishments discussed are the American Rescue Plan, major infrastructure legislation, the Respect for Marriage Act, the reauthorization of the Violence Against Women Act, and the Emmett Till Antilynching Act. Biden also discusses his administration’s efforts to rebuild international alliances and support Ukraine against Russian aggression.
The book is particularly effective when Biden explains the challenges facing his administration and the decisions he made in response. Although Mr. Book does not agree with every decision, Biden generally makes a persuasive case for his actions.
The section that most interested Mr. Book concerned the disastrous June 2024 presidential debate, the subsequent campaign to force Biden out of the presidential race, and his eventual decision to withdraw.
Mr. Book had been among those defending Biden’s decision to remain in the race, and he continued doing so until just a few days before Biden announced his withdrawal. Consequently, he was particularly interested in hearing Biden’s explanation of why he resisted the pressure to step aside.
Biden describes the aftermath of the debate, his efforts to demonstrate that he remained capable of campaigning effectively, and the growing pressure from Democratic leaders who had concluded that he could no longer win. He argues that the polling did not initially justify the widespread assumption that his candidacy was doomed and that the political narrative surrounding the debate became more damaging than the polling itself.
He also describes the difficult position of having won the Democratic primaries and secured the delegates necessary for renomination while influential party leaders and donors were demanding that he abandon his campaign. Biden believed he could still defeat Trump, and he was reluctant to surrender the nomination simply because others had lost confidence in him.
Ultimately, Biden concluded that continuing would leave the Democratic Party deeply divided. He explains his decision to withdraw and his subsequent endorsement of Kamala Harris, including his belief that a contested nomination battle would have been particularly destructive.
Mr. Book found Biden’s explanation convincing. He certainly was not going to criticize Biden for taking so long to reach a decision when Mr. Book himself had defended that decision for almost the entire period.
Unfortunately, there is one enormous omission that prevents this book from receiving an A or A+.
Jack Smith.
Throughout the book, Biden repeatedly emphasizes the importance of protecting American democracy and holding Donald Trump accountable for his conduct. He discusses Trump’s efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election, the January 6 insurrection, the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity decision, and the eventual collapse of the federal prosecutions against Trump.
Biden even cites Jack Smith’s conclusion that the evidence would have been sufficient to convict Trump had the prosecution been permitted to proceed.
But Biden never adequately confronts the question that Mr. Book considers essential:
Why wasn’t the federal investigation and prosecution of Trump pursued with the necessary urgency from the very beginning of Biden’s presidency?
Biden took office on January 20, 2021, following an insurrection intended to prevent the peaceful transfer of power. In Mr. Book’s view, ensuring that the federal government promptly pursued accountability for those responsible, including Trump himself, should have been among the administration’s highest priorities.
Instead, Jack Smith was not appointed special counsel until November 2022, nearly two years into Biden’s presidency.
By the time the prosecutions were underway, the approaching 2024 election and subsequent legal delays created an opportunity for Trump to escape a federal trial. His election victory ultimately brought the prosecutions to an end.
Mr. Book considers this a monumental failure.
The Constitution requires the president to take care that the laws be faithfully executed. Mr. Book believes Biden’s administration failed to meet that responsibility with the urgency demanded by the extraordinary circumstances of January 6.
This criticism does not depend on Biden personally directing a prosecution. It concerns his administration’s responsibility for ensuring that the Justice Department treated the attempted overthrow of a presidential election with the seriousness and urgency it deserved.
What makes the omission particularly troubling is that Biden repeatedly presents the preservation of democracy as one of the central missions of his presidency. Yet he does not satisfactorily explain why the administration allowed so much time to pass before the federal case against Trump reached the stage it should have reached much earlier.
Mr. Book doubts that any explanation would have persuaded him that the delay was justified. Nevertheless, Biden owed readers an explanation, and his failure to provide one is a serious weakness in an otherwise impressive book.
That omission is what ultimately reduced the grade from an A to a B+.
Despite that criticism, Promise Me, America exceeded Mr. Book’s expectations. Biden provides an informative and frequently persuasive account of his presidency, its accomplishments, its challenges, and the extraordinary political circumstances surrounding its conclusion.
And that leads to a final observation.
Mr. Book has never awarded a book an E. Indeed, there is no E in his grading system.
But if there were, this might have been the perfect occasion to use it.
After all, as George Weasley would appreciate, E stands for Exceeds Expectations.
And Promise Me, America certainly did that.
Mr. Book gives this book a B+. In Mr. Book’s conversion system, a B+ equates to 4 stars. (A or A+: 5 stars, B+: 4 stars, B: 3 stars, C: 2 stars, D or F: 1 star).
This review has been published at Mr. Book’s Book Reviews and Goodreads.
Mr. Book finished reading this book on November 18, 2026.
